Skip to main content

Health innocence

When I begin composing a new post in my head, I know it is time to write. I don't know if anyone has used the term "health innocence" before, but if not, I'm coining it now.* Since my lung cancer diagnosis, I have lost my health innocence. Health innocence is the belief that we and our closest loved ones will inhabit what Susan Sontag calls the Kingdom of the Well**, at least until we're senior citizens, when health problems can be expected and reciting a litany of ailments becomes the butt of jokes.

Now that I've crossed over to the Kingdom of the Sick, I no longer think of X health problem as outside of the realm of possibility--for me or anyone. After all, what is the likelihood that a super-healthy, 49-year-old runner who's never held a cigarette or lived or worked in highly polluted conditions would develop lung cancer? Or that less than a year earlier, my nephew would be diagnosed with colon cancer, on the cusp of turning 36? Exactly. 

Cancer was one of three possibilities that my pulmonologist in Germany initially laid out in June 2022, but truthfully, I never entertained the possibility that it could actually be cancer. The biopsy was just to rule it out. That swollen, painful vein on my foot 5 weeks later? Probably just a random injury, my German oncologist assured us. Nope, my instinct to worry was right: it was deep-vein thrombosis and the blood clot became a life-threatening pulmonary embolism. When the Impossible, Worst-Case Scenario happens to you, the veil is torn. There's no longer any illusion that we are immune to a scary health diagnosis, that it won't happen to us or someone we love.

Hence the anxiety I felt during the past 16 hours. Lily has been sick off and on since early March: one, possibly two, rounds of strep and lots of coughing even after antibiotics. Then this past Sunday her lymph nodes were swollen. On Monday it got worse, and then it began to hurt to swallow and open her mouth. Leland took her to the doctor yesterday: mono test was negative. They ordered some other blood tests whose results would arrive on Wednesday. Then last night Lily developed small red spots on the top of her mouth, similar to strep. I learned just before going to bed that this other test was for...leukemia. 

So of course I was overcome with worry and couldn't fall asleep for 2+ hours, while Leland woke up 2 hours early, both of us picking at this possible diagnosis like a hangnail. Last night and this morning, Lily became convinced her wisdom tooth was the problem. Back to doctor: strep test was negative. Got in to see our dentist, who said everything looked fine, except that there was visible irritation and swelling near the tooth. He thought the problem was something "systemic" (affecting the whole body), perhaps the last throes of a virus that manifested in the mouth. I had been hoping for a positive diagnosis so we would know what it was. Some of Lily's symptoms were associated with leukemia -- there are medical journal articles with titles like "Oral manifestations of leukemia as part of early diagnosis" -- and of course a lot of less scary things, but we'd ruled out the obvious culprits.

Leland called the doctor again around 1pm today and got the test results already: negative for leukemia, and all the other indicators look fine. The doctor thinks it's some random virus. 

I've always been prone to worry, but I'm not a hypochondriac. Before my diagnosis, I would have just assumed this was some minor thing. Now that the Unthinkable has happened to me and my family, I can't not think it. There's no reason the Worst-Case Scenario can't happen again. Sometimes lightning does strike twice. And with my health catastrophe track record, I'm half-way expecting it to.

It's hard enough not to catastrophize if you've never experienced a health catastrophe (or two), and nearly impossible when you have. I find a rational approach ("How realistic is it that X will happen?") utterly unhelpful, because I've already been on the losing end of infinitesimally small chances. "There's only a tiny chance that it could happen" is no longer reassuring. When you've crossed from the Kingdom of the Well to the Kingdom of the Sick, you realize a few breaths and heartbeats are all that separate the two kingdoms. It's a porous border.

So what do you do when you've lost your health innocence? As my friend Melissa put it, "if it's not good news, we will rally and fight and do all the things we now know how to do that we wish we didn't." 

I'm thankful we didn't need this plan today. I've gotten better with worrying about my own health (no more reading those CT scan reports ahead of time!). However, now that I'm dwelling in the Kingdom of the Sick, I realize that I need a new plan for managing worries about the health of loved ones.

* A quick Google and Google Scholar search suggests I may indeed have coined this term! 

** “Illness is the night side of life, a more onerous citizenship. Everyone who is born holds dual citizenship, in the kingdom of the well and in the kingdom of the sick. Although we all prefer to use the good passport, sooner or later each of us is obliged, at least for a spell, to identify ourselves as citizens of that other place.” (Sontag, Illness as Metaphor, https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1978/01/26/illness-as-metaphor/) This metaphor was also the basis of Suleika Jaouad's book, Between Two Kingdoms

Comments

  1. This is so well written and real; I feel like once we are subjected to health traumas our brains seem inclined to wire and fire differently to “help us”prepare for the next unforeseeable disaster in hopes that we will somehow be ready…if only... I appreciate your reframing it through your friend Melissa’s encouraging words. I am incredibly relieved to hear this news regarding Lily. Thank you for sharing with us and allowing us to be a part of your journey.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. Thank you, friend. I was thinking of you during this ordeal.

      Delete
  2. This is very deep. I’ve never seen you as sick this whole time. I always pray for you to experience wellness. You encourage me. God is blessing you through it all. Sorry Lily has been so sick. I know that was agonizing to wait for results. To God be the glory it all worked out. Praying whatever virus stays far away from her forever! 🙏🏽🙏🏽

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Alisa. I appreciate your constant support. L seems to be on the mend, thankfully. So much volleyball takes a toll (e.g., Saturday night they finished playing at 9:45pm and had to be at the court by 7am the next morning).

      Delete
  3. Beautifully expressed, Esther. And wonderful relief about Lily.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This reminded me of other life situations, when making plans becomes truncated by something we endure. It’s not just the thing itself, but that we can’t plan like we once assumed we could, before. I used to call it ‘taking off the cellophane’ to what life actually is. You can see it, sometimes clearly in others, but once it’s removed… like health innocence… no turning back, (unless you stuff things)
    We like to think we would hit hard times only every now and again, but if we live in community we know what an unrealistic view THAT is… for me, life is like swimming in an unfiltered biome, especially as the years add up. The rotation of befores, durings, and now whats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, long-term planning is pretty much out the window. Initially, short-term planning was, too. Going through Hard Things shatters the illusion of control.

      Delete
  5. As the aforementioned Melissa, I would like to thank Esther for being the consummate good friend, because as sure as I eventually offered something helpful, I also was at least one documented source of all the utterly unhelpful references she mentioned as well. (Seriously, the lightning comment was a direct quote and not the only one). She so kindly didn’t call me out publicly for being obtuse and this post is the most beautiful retort. I’m sorry I didn’t say all the right things today, Esther. My heart was in the right place but I understand now why it didn’t help allay your worries. I love you. We all do. I’m as lucky to call you friend as Lily is not to have leukemia. 🤣 Hope she feels better soon. 💜

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Meliss. As I texted you (and now post publicly), my comments weren't directed at you, and you did help allay my worries. I was mainly reflecting on the dominant (cognitive behavioral therapy) approach to managing worry, which is to examine whether your fears are rational or realistic.

      Delete
  6. Wow, Esther. I'm relieved to hear that Lily is negative for Lukemia. I completely understand your worries, but truly sorry that the Kingdom of the Sick creates such fear and worry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, friend. It's not possible to go back to the days of health innocence!

      Delete
  7. That is good news about Lily but not great she was sick for so long. Thank you for sharing your heart and wisdom. You are right about “health innocence” and the risks of wandering too far. ❤️ —your neighbor Michelle

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

regular update

I had my regular oncology appointment in Pittsburgh yesterday. Dr. Villaruz said the scans look good and everything is stable. Although I don’t have much scanxiety nowadays, it’s always a relief to get good news. Just to be sure that my understanding was correct, I asked her why I’m not a candidate for surgery. It’s because of the cancer’s growth pattern. The one nodule that’s visible on the CT scan could just be scarring; she’s not sure if it’s a tumor. When I was diagnosed, I was told the lung cancer was “lepidic.” This means that the tumor cells were growing along the lining of the alveolar structures (air sacs).* That’s why my lungs looked like they were draped in cobwebs. You can’t do surgery in enough places to get all of it. Thankfully, Tagrisso swept out those cobwebs – and continues to do so. We go back in December for a regular appointment. *Lepidic spread tends to be slow-growing, with minimal invasion of nearby tissues, less chance of metastasis, and overall better progno...

38.6 months

September 18 marked 38.6 months (3 years, 2 months, 18 days) since I first started taking Tagrisso. Why is 38.6 months significant? Because it is the median overall survival in the FLAURA study, a landmark study (2014-16) comparing Tagrisso and older targeted therapies among patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer, EGFR mutation, and no prior treatment. 279 patients received Tagrisso and 277 people received an older drug (in addition, all patients received at least one dose of a trial drug). Nearly 58% of patients had died when data collection stopped. However, patients in the Tagrisso group lived nearly 7 months longer (median) than the control group. When Leland and I initially read that number – 38.6 months – in the Tagrisso promotional materials, we were stunned. This was supposed to be good news? The median age in the FLAURA study was 64 and at the time (August 2022), I had just turned 50. But still, it was a sobering statistic. For the longest time, I didn't feel ...

A failure of institutional care

I just hit "send" on this letter to my dean and associate dean. Mic drop. I've never sent such a scathing letter, but it's definitely called for in this situation. I'm not expecting anything other than a "Oh, that wasn't how we intended to make you feel; our hands were tied" email. Dear Dean Lawless and Associate Dean Lloyd, When I wrote to Professor Land [my department head] to see if I could get a course release this fall due to having lung cancer plus complications from pulmonary embolism and COVID, I had no idea what I was in for. When faculty friends in other colleges have had health crises (ones that don’t warrant a full-semester medical leave), their department head or dean has simply said, “Don’t worry about teaching this semester. We’ll figure it out.” I figured the same would happen in my case. To be blunt, the way that my case was handled was a colossal failure of leadership. As my husband and I have shared my story with colleagues at PSU ...